MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Illinois AG Sues Dealer for Deceptive Sales Tactics

Illinois Attorney General Lisa Madigan files lawsuit against a Carterville auto dealer for deceptive sales tactics. The Illinois dealer allegedly promised repair guarantees on cars sold “as is” but didn’t follow through.

by Staff
May 2, 2013
2 min to read


CHICAGO — Attorney General Lisa Madigan filed a lawsuit against a Carterville-based auto dealership for deceptive sales tactics.

Madigan’s lawsuit, filed today in Williamson County Circuit Court, alleges that Kevin Darnell and his company, RTO Auto Sales, sold used cars “as is” and falsely promised either that the vehicle was in good condition or that if mechanical problems occurred, he would repair the vehicles.

However, according to the complaint, Darnell allegedly failed to make the promised repairs and refused to refund consumers who had purchased faulty vehicles. Madigan’s suit also alleges Darnell promised but failed to pay off at least one consumer’s loan on a trade-in vehicle, and in some cases, failed to remit costs for license plates, titles and sales taxes.

“Based on the complaints we’ve received, this dealer took customers for a ride, failing to fulfill the many promises he made to induce customers into buying faulty vehicles,” Madigan said.

The Attorney General’s office has received nine complaints against Darnell and RTO Auto, with area customers reporting anywhere from $500 to nearly $3,500 in losses. One consumer reportedly purchased a vehicle “as is,” but with the promise that RTO Auto would make repairs as needed. Within five hours of buying the vehicle, the car began to overheat and coolant was leaking from the radiator. After the consumer returned the car to RTO Auto, Darnell promised to make the necessary repairs at no cost. Within four days of receiving the supposedly repaired vehicle, the car’s engine failed.

According to the complaint, Darnell refused to provide a refund but promised to exchange a functioning car for the defective vehicle. The exchanged vehicle stopped running within six days. Ultimately, after Darnell refused to refund the customer’s money or provide a fully operational car, the consumer paid nearly $800 for needed repairs on the exchanged vehicle.

Additionally, Madigan’s suit alleges that because Darnell failed to pay off a loan on a trade-in vehicle in at least one case, the consumer remained financially responsible for a trade-in vehicle he no longer possessed. That consumer says his credit rating consequently suffered.

Madigan’s lawsuit asks the court to enter a permanent injunction against the dealership. The complaint also asks the court to order Darnell and RTO Auto to pay restitution to consumers, a $50,000 civil penalty, an additional $50,000 penalty for each violation of the Consumer Fraud Act, as well as all fees associated with the investigation and prosecution of the case.

More Compliance

ComplianceNovember 26, 2025

Turnover and Compliance

Why ongoing training is a necessity

Read More →
F&INovember 10, 2025

Singing a Gospel Song Backward

Crime and punishment in auto retail and how to avoid them

Read More →
ComplianceSeptember 26, 2025

The Best Thing a Dealer Can Do to Avoid Legal Problems

Citing the issue is a strategy borrowed from the legal field itself.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
ComplianceSeptember 15, 2025

Fines of the Times

Civil penalties for noncompliance with federal auto retail and finance rules and regulations can add up quickly. Use this checklist to cover your bases.

Read More →
ComplianceAugust 26, 2025

Goodwill and Car Dealers

A dealer goodwill tale is a cautionary tale worth paying attention to.

Read More →
ComplianceAugust 11, 2025

Your Synthetic ID Theft Policy

Frankenstein’s monster is coming for your dealership. Use this guide to recognize synthetic ID thieves and maintain Red Flags Rule compliance.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
ComplianceJune 30, 2025

The Regulatory Empire Is Striking Back

President Trump - entropist and corporate disruptor in consumer law

Read More →
IndustryJune 26, 2025

How to Clear a Red Flag

Refine and enforce your dealership’s FTC-mandated ID theft-prevention program to ensure no transaction goes awry.

Read More →
Computer screen showing the Audit F&I Review Dashboard, displaying dealership selection and manager scorecard options for ABC Dealership.
F&Iby Press ReleaseJune 18, 2025

Mosaic Adds Continuous Monitoring With AuditF&I

New AuditF&I platform is designed to give dealerships a smarter way to stay compliant.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
IndustryMay 28, 2025

Mount Rushmore and Tariffs

A return to autarky? Are tariffs good policy?

Read More →