MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Dealer Group Accuses Maserati of Inflating Sales Numbers

A New York-based dealer group has filed a $200 million lawsuit against Maserati, claiming that the OEM inflated sales numbers and rewarded dealers who participated in its illegal schemes.

September 3, 2015
Dealer Group Accuses Maserati of Inflating Sales Numbers

 

2 min to read


NEW YORK — A dealer group has filed a $200 million lawsuit against Maserati North America (MNA), claiming the OEM launched discriminatory dealer incentive programs in order to present “an image of greater value of financial strength” prior to the initial public offering of its parent company, Fiat Chrysler Automobiles.

Filed on Aug. 28 by Recovery Racing — which operates a chain of Maserati dealerships in New York, New Jersey and Florida — the lawsuit alleges that MNA launched in 2014 an illegal vehicle-punching scheme that rewarded complicit dealerships with incentives and reduced expenses.

Recovery Racing owner Stuart Hayim, who is being represented by Leonard Bellavia and Steven Blatt of law firm Bellavia Blatt & Crossett, alleged that dealers were instructed by MNA’s Regional Sales Vice President Rick Fuller to “punch” — or record the sale of — new 2015 Ghibli vehicles before the cars were even delivered to their dealerships.

“Those dealers that were complicit with this fraudulent scheme received hundreds of thousands of dollars in incentive monies,” the complaint read, in part.

The scheme resulted in MNA reporting a 300% increase in retail sales in October 2014, according to the lawsuit, despite hundreds of those vehicles not having been sold to retail customers.

Dealers who participated in the scheme were rewarded through “discriminatory” dealer incentive programs, according to the suit. If they met the OEM’s monthly sales objectives, those dealers would receive retroactive incentive payments for each vehicle sold, essentially allowing them to purchase and sell new Maserati vehicles at substantially lower prices than their competitors.

And while the sales goals set for Recovery Racing were at five to seven times the number of Maserati vehicles it had historically sold, “other, newer, Maserati dealerships (with no substantive sales history) received more favorable pricing through the bonus program,” according to the complaint, because their sales objectives were based on their lower market share and short sales history and therefore more reasonable. Those dealers were effectively able to undercut other Maserati dealers — including Recovery Racing — with no impact to their bottom line, the lawsuit charged.

MNA also allegedly told dealers that it would cease to reimburse them for the “holdback” fees they were charged in addition to the wholesale price of a vehicle if that vehicle was sold outside the dealership’s territory.

“In addition … MNA advised certain of the then operating plaintiffs, without justification or cause, that certain of their dealership territories would be reduced, thereby further reducing the territories in which they could sell new Maserati vehicles and be paid holdback monies,” the lawsuit stated.

MNA had not returned requests for comment at the time of publication.

More Compliance

ComplianceNovember 26, 2025

Turnover and Compliance

Why ongoing training is a necessity

Read More →
F&INovember 10, 2025

Singing a Gospel Song Backward

Crime and punishment in auto retail and how to avoid them

Read More →
ComplianceSeptember 26, 2025

The Best Thing a Dealer Can Do to Avoid Legal Problems

Citing the issue is a strategy borrowed from the legal field itself.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
ComplianceSeptember 15, 2025

Fines of the Times

Civil penalties for noncompliance with federal auto retail and finance rules and regulations can add up quickly. Use this checklist to cover your bases.

Read More →
ComplianceAugust 26, 2025

Goodwill and Car Dealers

A dealer goodwill tale is a cautionary tale worth paying attention to.

Read More →
ComplianceAugust 11, 2025

Your Synthetic ID Theft Policy

Frankenstein’s monster is coming for your dealership. Use this guide to recognize synthetic ID thieves and maintain Red Flags Rule compliance.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
ComplianceJune 30, 2025

The Regulatory Empire Is Striking Back

President Trump - entropist and corporate disruptor in consumer law

Read More →
IndustryJune 26, 2025

How to Clear a Red Flag

Refine and enforce your dealership’s FTC-mandated ID theft-prevention program to ensure no transaction goes awry.

Read More →
Computer screen showing the Audit F&I Review Dashboard, displaying dealership selection and manager scorecard options for ABC Dealership.
F&Iby Press ReleaseJune 18, 2025

Mosaic Adds Continuous Monitoring With AuditF&I

New AuditF&I platform is designed to give dealerships a smarter way to stay compliant.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
IndustryMay 28, 2025

Mount Rushmore and Tariffs

A return to autarky? Are tariffs good policy?

Read More →